Perspectives on building sustainable newborn screening programs for sickle cell disease: Experiences from Tanzania

4.1.1 Feasibility of conducting NBS for SCD

Both implementers and policy makers were positive on the possibility of establishing NBS for SCD programs in regional referral hospitals (RRH) where specialized care for SCD already existed. The strategy was to start the programs in well-resourced RRH and then moving to district hospitals (DH). Challenges addressed by the clinicians as well as policy makers were on laboratory diagnostics, specialized training to the health care providers and the need for high level advocacy to ensure government support in the implementation.

“We have also talked about policy makers and how we can take them on board to ensure newborn screening for sickle cell disease is prioritized. If we succeed in doing that then all the activities will be budgeted by the Ministry of Health [NBS for SCD], having its own budget it will be easy for the implementers. Also, the hospital will need to have qualified personnel who are knowledgeable about the program to provide education to the families. The same with Laboratory diagnostics and other interventions. Since hematologists are very few in Tanzania, we will have to encourage our doctors to pursue those trainings and our nurses to fully implement the programs” 1_IDI_Implementers_Paediatrician_MRRH_06.08.18

4.1.2 Acceptability of NBS for SCD

Participants in all the three categories acknowledge the benefits of NBS for SCD. Nurses who were working in the programs explained that very few mothers refuse to screen their newborn babies for SCD. This observation was also consistent during the interviews with families, mothers recall that during the screening most mothers were keen to screen their newborn babies for SCD. The few refusals were linked to low knowledge of SCD. Parents who already have children with SCD were more interested to know the results and initiate requests to screen their newborn babies than those who did not have children with SCD.

“From our experiences of screening these children for sickle cell disease, we never had a situation where mothers will refuse to screen their babies for whatever reasons. Most of them are happy to get their children screened. We never had refusal based on certain culture [or tribe] not allowing newborn babies to be screened” 1-FGD_Implementers_Nurses_Postnatal Unit_TRRH_07.08.18

During the discussion with nurses from Amana hospital, one of the nurses who had prior experience of working in screening programs, suggested low knowledge of the disease in the communities as potential reason that may lead to refusal to screen.

“Mothers may find it hard to accept because of the little understanding they have about the disease, but when you educate them then it is easy to accept screening their children. So, her own understanding will influence her to screen the child. We also tell the mothers the benefits of knowing early if your child is born with the disease” 2_FGD_Implementers_Nurses_Neonatal Unit_ARRH_27.08.18

Acceptability of the screening was also linked to having family history of the disease, as indicated during a dyad-interview with a mother and father of a child with SCD diagnosed through NBS.

“For me when I gave birth, the nurse came and advise us or may be requested us to screen our children for sickle cell disease, and she asked us, are you ready? and because I know this problem is there [in her family] I was also attracted to screen my child for sickle cell, and I say okay I am ready. They took the blood, and they promise to call us to give us the result back” 5_IDI_Families_both parents_30.01.2019

4.1.3 Education and Counselling to families

In hospitals with ongoing screening services, nurses acknowledge education and counselling need to be integrated in the services. Lack of adequate number of nurses in the postnatal wards limit time that nurses may use for educating families. Suggestion were made for health education to start at the antenatal clinics to ensure mothers are educated about SCD before the actual screening. Another challenge raised during the interviews was nurses themselves felt that they do not have enough knowledge on SCD to competently and comprehensively provide counselling and health education to the families.

“Education to nurses is needed for them to provide counselling to the families. It is difficult to counsel or educate another person if you don’t have enough knowledge of the disease” 7_IDI_Implementers_Haematologist_TRRH_14.09.18

In the group interview with mothers who participated in the screening program, they pointed out the need to have detailed education session on SCD. Since the health education included other issues related to child-care the SCD part was felt by the mothers to be very small.

“However, the education provided was a small bit of everything, we are educated not only about sickle cell even how to breastfeed our babies. Therefore, we did not think of even asking questions on sickle cell-M1 (Probe: so, when do you think is the right time to provide the education) Education has to start in the antenatal clinics, because the day when we gave birth, the mother is being told so many things, you cannot remember everything” 1_FGD_Families_TRRH_01.09.18

4.2.1 Availability of comprehensive care services

All the RRH that participated in this study have specialized clinics for SCD at least once per week. The average number of patients consulted in the clinics’ ranges from 20 to 32 weekly. The clinics are attended by nurses, doctors specialized in providing care for sickle cell patients and/ or hematologist and pediatrician. The sickle cell clinics are well integrated services through the existing health care infrastructure. The key issue highlighted throughout the discussion was a need to establish sickle cell clinics in the primary health care facilities and availability of diagnostic tests.

“The most challenging aspect is diagnostic tests, but sickle cell clinics have been there in some of the regional referral hospitals, and we do have data in terms of the number of patients visiting those clinics for over the years” 1-IDI_Policy makers_ Coordinator of SCD programs, Ministry of Health_20.08.2018

4.2.1 Accessibility of comprehensive care services

Since most of the specialized care for SCD are in regional referral hospitals as illustrated in figure 4 below. Families are required to travel fairly a long distance to access care. Lack of money for transport was linked to poor clinic attendance for some families. One of the suggestions provided by nurses who closely work with the families was to introduce services in health care facilities in primary and secondary and build capacity to provide specialized care for SCD. This solution will also redistribute the burden of care so that the RRHs provide specialized care for SCD who are not managed at primary and secondary health facilities. Families were also concerned by the level of care provided at primary and secondary health care facilities and reiterated the suggestion to provide trainings on specialized care for SCD at all levels of health care.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 4. Illustration of Health Service Levels and Referral system in Tanzania

“It is also important to do follow ups with patients if they are not attending clinics, but if we just wait for patients to come to the clinic [without follow ups] then there are many patients who cannot come to clinics because they don’t have money for transport. The child may be sick, and they will not be able to bring them to the hospital. Temeke is so big people are coming from different places and if all the children will have to come to Temeke, it is not going to be possible” 1-FGD_Implementers_Nurses_Postnatal Unit_TRRH_07.08.18

4.2.3 Affordability of the health care services

According to the government policy, children under five years of age and those suffering from chronic illnesses such as SCD, can access health care for free. This policy has enabled most of the families to bring their children to the clinics for care. However, implementers acknowledge the challenges in the implementation of the exemption policies. Inconsistencies on the availability of the essential medicines like Penicillin and Folic acid require parents to sometimes pay for the medicines out of pockets. The National Health Insurance Fund (NHIF) that is also considered as one of the possible solutions to subsidize health care costs for children under 18 years of age. At the time of the interviews, all the thirteen (13) families interviewed in this study their children were not insured by the NHIF.

“[P1] The government policy require children with chronic illness to access care for free, so for pediatric sickle cell clinic, drugs are given for free. I am not sure if Penicillin is available [they might be asked to go and buy) but folic acid is given for free. [P2] We encourage families to buy insurance for their children, most parents believe that if you have children under five then everything is free, but it is not everything, insurance will be able to pay so many things” 4_FGD_Implementers_Nurses_Neonatal Unit_MRRH_09.08.18

During one of the family interviews, there were concerns that not all parents will be able to buy insurance package for their children, suggestion was made to treat sickle cell patients for free.

“With regard to the services, we just need to have the health insurance, for those who don’t have insurance they are getting so many difficulties, for example the other day when I came to the clinic, that thing for taking out blood [Cannula?], I was told to go and buy it, sometime there are no drugs you have to pay out of pocket, so those are some of the challenges. Some families don’t have money to pay for the services or buy the insurance. The only solution is for sickle cell patients to be treated for free” 11_IDI_Families_15.02.2019

4.2.4 Trainings for HCPs and Human Resources for Health Crises

Training in genetic counselling, diagnostic methods and management of SCD were considered to be important by the implementers and policy makers. Nurses acknowledged that once they receive the right training in SCD and genetic counselling, they will be better equipped to educate families.

“Training are still needed, on our side [nurses] we need to be trained before we start educating families. If we are knowledgeable about the disease, the benefits of screening and the management options available, then it will be easy to educate the families” 3_FGD_Implementers_Nurses_Postnatal Unit_MRRH_09.08.18

The interview with the head of pediatric unit in one of the RRH emphasized the importance of creating sustainable training plans. Instead of focusing on individuals, the training should be tailored to benefit majority of the staff in the respective units.

“Since this service is new then, the nurses will need refresher training for those who will be responsible for running the programs. And also we should not select one or two people to get the training, because other staff will wait until that person is around to do the work [the program become this person project] or telling the families come another day the [nurse] is not around. So if it will include postnatal unit then all the nurses need to be trained [how to screen, how to transport the sample and the diagnostic aspect] it has to be integrated with the hospital structure. If you use one or two person you will need to pay them and that will bring segregation amongst the staff” 5_IDI_Implementers_Paediatrician_TRRH_13.08.18

4.3.1 Expanding NBS to include other diseases

Healthcare providers and policy makers both agreed that expanding NBS services for SCD to include other conditions, could be one of cost-effective approach to leverage the limited resources. Suggested newborn disorders that can be added to include HIV screening, hearing disorders, down syndrome and other physical abnormalities such as talipes.

“Expanding the screening services will give us an opportunity to do so many tests under one umbrella, so the same DBS samples can be used to screen other diseases such as HIV. Now, the question is do we have the resources to do all the tests? but as a recommendation I think we should think of it [expanding] the issues of resources will come after we are ready. The primary aim is to benefit the child” IDI_DMO_Ilala_Policymaker_20.08.18

Similar suggestion was also provided during the FGDs with nurses at TRRH

“This needs to be advocated to the ministry [expanding NBS programs] to involve other diseases as a way of minimizing the costs for screening instead of just screening for one disease. Although this feels like a very long-term plan” 2_FGD_Implementers_Nurses_Neonatal Unit_ARRH_27.08.18

Bugando hospital in Mwanza did a pilot project to screen SCD through the DBS sample collected for HIV screening. However, since newborn screening for HIV is only done for children born with HIV positive mothers only fewer groups will be able to benefit.

“We did a pilot program to screen all newborn babies for sickle cell disease born in Bugando hospital centers but due to issues of reagents we had to stop. And we did start another program to screen only a small population of children born with exposed mothers [children who were less than 24 months] since all the DBS are coming to our hospitals from all regions, we thought this is a very good platform to screen for Sickle Cell Disease. We have completed this project three weeks ago, and I can say the prevalence is still very high” 3_IDI_Implementers_Paediatrician_BMC_15.08.18

4.3.2 Engaging with private sector

Partnering with private health facilities and diagnostic laboratories to sustain implementation of the screening programs appear to be a feasible sustainable approach. The Hematology Clinical and Research laboratory (HCRL-Public) at MUHAS partnered with the Aga Khan hospital (AKH-Private) in Dar es Salaam in processing NBS samples. The costs paid by AKH allow the laboratory to sustain itself through buying reagents and also subsidize the testing costs for samples from public health facilities.

“At the ministry of health, we have a section that only deals with public private partnership and also another section that deals with private health facilities and also diagnostic service department. Through those resources we can assess in what ways we can benefit from each other especially in the area of diagnosis. We are aware that private health facilities are doing a number of screening, so yes there is a lot that we can learn and leverage from each other” 2_IDI_MoHGEC_Policy Maker_01.08.18

4.3.3 Expansion of services to primary and secondary HCF

Providing essential training to HCPs working in primary health care facilities was suggested as a strategy to sustain the comprehensive care services for SCD. This will help to distribute the workload across the different levels of care and can potentially reduce the burden of care in regional referral hospitals and zonal hospitals.

“We are hoping for the best on the newborn screening for Sickle Cell Disease, whatever we are doing there [in the referral hospitals] can also be done in primary and secondary health care facilities. We can start piloting the programs in regional referral hospitals like Temeke, it is still possible to collect DBS in primary as well as secondary health care facilities with much higher number of births. Sample can be collected daily and processed in a centralized laboratory [Muhimbili] Nurses that have been trained here in Temeke can train other nurses in the health facilities” 5_IDI_Implementers_Paediatrician_TRRH_13.08.18

4.3.4 Integration within existing health care infrastructures

Except for BMC, NBS for SCD programs are currently implemented in public health hospitals. HCP, pharmacies and laboratories are supported by the government. The only gap that the NBS program is fully covering is related to laboratory diagnosis. In-service training was provided to nurses and clinicians working in those public hospitals. The specialized clinics for SCD are part of the pediatrics clinics for the hospitals.

“If we want these services [NBS for SCD] to be sustainable it has to be part of the hospital plans, it has to be one of the services offered in the hospital and not a funded program that when the donors leave then the project is not there. If it will be part of the hospital services, then it can be sustained even at a lowest scale possible. This means when the hospital is doing budgeting if there are any reagents or laboratory diagnostics then will be budgeted” 2_FGD_Implementers_Nurses_Neonatal Unit_ARRH_27.08.18

4.3.5 Targeted NBS programs for SCD: only screen children born from pregnant women with SCT

Other proposed suggestions to sustainably implement NBS for SCD in limited resource settings was to only screen those at-risk children born through parents with SCT. Health care workers believed that this approach will be more cost effective in lowering down the screening costs. Mothers who have sickle cell trait will be captured through the antenatal clinic. Screening for SCD at birth will only be done to newborns whose mothers have positive test results. This model is similar to that adapted for HIV screening at birth.

“Families where mothers will be identified to have sickle cell trait, then the children will have to be screened. The antenatal card can be used to capture this information [this is within our ability] On my side I will take this forward and start implementing” 1_IDI_DMO_Ilala_Policymaker_20.08.18

4.3.7 Advocacy

There are two types of advocacy which is being done. The first level of advocacy is with patients’ groups to build awareness and provide education to the public on SCD. The contribution of these campaigns is having a community which is knowledgeable about the disease and willing to allow children to be screened for the disease. The second level of advocacy is with government officials and policy makers.

“We are doing advocacy campaigns targeting the community as well as the decision makers [government officials, policy makers]. For example, the school campaigns program that we are currently involved to build awareness amongst secondary school children. With regard to the government and Ministry, we are trying to provide evidence on how big this problem is and what are the possible solutions. We do believe with continuous advocacy we can achieve our goals” Member of the SCD taskforce, Ministry of Health “So again, that’s a policy issue and I think that’s why for me it’s almost impossible to talk about anything in isolation because we need multiple initiatives at the same time. So, while we are doing NBS we are also supposed to be talking to the Government about what we are doing [through providing evidence], our role should be advising– for what works and what doesn’t. If it has to be sustainable at some point, we need to see the Government owning the program. So how can that be? I think it’s going to be a very slow process; the most important thing is we are going in that direction” IDI_Implementers _NBS for SCD Coordinator_Sickle Cell Program_07.022019