Clinical characteristics of 36 non-survivors with COVID-19 in Wuhan, China

Introduction

The outbreak of Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) caused by severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) happened since December 2020 in Wuhan¹. ² SARS-CoV-2 has been spreading in China as well as in other countries^3–6. The outbreak of SARS-CoV-2 infection has been declared as a Public Health Emergency of International Concern by the World Health Organization (WHO) on 30 January 2020. According to the situation report from WHO, as of 21 February 2020, SARS-Cov-2 infection has caused 76769 confirmed cases in 27 countries and 2247 deaths globally⁷.

Severity of COVID-19 varied from mild to severe.⁸ Mortality rate of COVID-19 can be reduced, by timely identifying those who are at higher risk of developing into critically ill patients, closely monitoring changes of their disease course, and applying intensive care treatment to these patients. However, reports about dead cases of COVID-19 were limited but warranted, considering the large amount of confirmed cases, which is still increasing. In this single-centered study, we retrospectively analysed specific clinical information of 36 non-survivors infected with SARS-CoV-2.

Methods

Results

We included 36 patients who died from COVID-19 in the Fifth Hospital of Wuhan. One (2.78%) patients had a history of exposure to the Huanan seafood market in Wuhan. The mean age of the patients was 69.22 years (SD 9.64, range 50-90). Twenty-five (69.44%) patients were males, and 11 (30.56%) female. Four (11.11%) patients have smoking history. Twenty-six (72.22%) patients had chronic diseases. The most common chronic diseases were hypertension (21, 58.33%), cardiovascular (8, 22.22%) and diabetes (7, 19.44%) (Table 1).

On admission, most patients had fever, cough and more than half of them had shortness of breath (Table 2). Other symptoms included fatigue, dyspnea, sputum production, disturbance of consciousness, diarrhea, hemoptysis and myalgia. (Table 2). Patients had common clinical symptoms of fever (34, 94.44%), cough (28, 38.89%), shortness of breath (21, 58.33%), fatigue (17, 47.22%), dyspnea (14, 38.89%), sputum production (8, 22.22%), disturbance of consciousness (8, 22.22%), diarrhea (3, 8.33%), hemoptysis (2, 5.56%), and muscle ache (1, 2.78%).

According to chest CT scan, 31 (96.88%, N=32) patients showed bilateral pneumonia (75%). On admission, leucocytes were below the normal range in 5 (14.71%) patients and above the normal range in 11 (32.35%) patients (Table 3). Neutrophils showed above the normal range in 16 (47.06%) patients. Lymphocytes and hemoglobin were below the normal range in many patients (Table 3). Twelve (35.39%) patients’ platelets were below the normal range. 22 patients had varying degrees of liver function abnormality, with alanine aminotransferase (ALT) or aspartate aminotransferase (AST) rose above the normal range (Table 3). Elevation of lactate dehydrogenase were showed in 26 (100%, N=26) patients. About 30% of these patients had different degrees of renal function damage, with elevated blood urea nitrogen or serum creatinine.

Regarding the infection index, procalcitonin (PCT) rose above the normal range in 28 (100%) patients. 11 patients were tested for IL-6, most of whose index were above the normal range (Table 3). 32 patients had increased C-reactive protein (CRP).

Thirty-five (35, 97.22%) patients received antiviral treatment, including oseltamivir, ganciclovir, ribavirin or umifenovir hydrochloride. All patients were given antibiotic treatment (Table 2); 14 (38.89%) patients with a single antibiotic and 22 (61.11%) patients with combination therapy. 25 (69.44%) patients were also treated with glucocorticoids, and 20 (55.56%) patients treated with intravenous immunoglobulin therapy. Six patients have received aerosol inhalation treatment with a-IFN. Almost all the patients (35, 97.22%) received oxygen therapy, in which 19 (52.78%) patients used non-invasive ventilator mechanical ventilation and 9 (25%) patients used an invasive ventilator to assist ventilation.

All the cases had developed into Acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS). The median time from onset to ARDS was 11 days (Supplementary Figure 1). One (2.78%) patient presented with acute renal injury before ARDS. Electrolyte disturbance occurred in 16 patients (44.44%, Table 2). The median time from onset to death was 17 days (Figure 1).

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 1.

Survival curves of 36 non-survivors with COVID-19 in the Fifth Hospital of Wuhan. A. calculated from onset; B. calculated from hospitalization.

Discussion

We reported on 36 patients who died from SARS-CoV-2 infection in a single hospital of Wuhan. All these patients had ARDS and 28 (77.78%) patients needed mechanical ventilation. Bilateral pneumonia was detected in most patients on admission. Previous studies have shown that elder patients and males who were confirmed with coronavirus infection are at higher risk of ARDS, ¹⁰ which was consistent with our study. Antibiotic treatment was used to prevent secondary infections since these patients were critically ill. Antiviral regimes were also used in most patients which we hoped may have roles but still need more data. However, there were no specific remedies for SARS-CoV-2 yet^11,12. Therefore, most patients were treated with supportive treatment and intensive care. Unfortunately, due to restrictions of hospital’s conditions and the heavy burden of COVID-19 in Wuhan City, neither were we able to provide patients in need with advanced life support systems like Extracorporeal Membrane Oxygenation (ECMO), nor were able to transport all serious patients to superior hospital for better medical treatments in time. The median survival time of the patients in our study was only 2 weeks approximately, which was shorter compared to previous reports¹³. According to the study conducted by Yang et al., the mortality rate in critically ill patients with COVID-19 was higher than that in critically ill patients with SARS. To help patients who were critically ill survive from SARS-CoV-2 infection, advanced life support systems and other more intensive care are needed. In our cohort, non-survivors were hospitalized at 10 days after onset, and most of patients develop into ARDS within the first 3 days after admission (Supplementary Figure 1). This concentratedly reflected the current situation under the outbreak and was closely related to the run-up of medical resources. Early detection and intervention of patients are especially important which can delay the development from mild to severe cases. Encouragingly, more intensive care units (ICU) are being constructed, and more specialists and clinicians from different regions in China are assembling in medical institutions in Wuhan. Ultimately, the mortality of COVID-19 will decrease as the clinical capacity improves.

As reported in previous studies, patients who are male, elder or have a history of cerebrovascular disease are at higher risk of SARS-CoV-2 infection^2,14,15. In our study, we found that the majority of coronavirus non-survivors were male patients, elder patients and patients with chronic diseases, which indicated that these patients might be also at increased risk of becoming critically ill or death. Cerebrovascular diseases were the most common comorbidities. Twenty-two (61.11%) non-survivors had cerebrovascular diseases in our report, and the percentage of cerebrovascular diseases among non-survivors was higher than that reported by Yang et al¹³. Besides, there were 4 (11.11%) non-survivors who had smoking history and 4 (11.11%) had preexisting COPD. According to previous studies on middle east respiratory syndrome coronavirus (MERS-CoV), smokers and COPD patients might be susceptible to MERS. Further, compared to non-smokers, smokers and COPD patients had a higher dipeptidyl peptidase IV (DPP4) expression, which was inversely correlated with lung function and diffusing capacity parameters¹⁶. Although the relationship between smoking history and susceptibility as well as worse outcomes in COVID-19 remains unclear, we cautioned that the prognosis of COVID-19 in patients with smoking history might be more severe.

In our cohort, lymphocytopenia occurred in more than 70% of patients at admission, which is a main laboratory feature in COVID-19 patients^15,17. Lymphocytopenia have been identified in the critically ill patients with SARS-CoV and MERS infection^18,19. As mentioned in previous studies, the severity of lymphocytopenia might indicate the severity of COVID-19, under the assumption of SARS-CoV-2 viral could attack and destroy the lymphocyte targetedly². Further studies are warranted to confirm these findings. Increased levels of serum CRP, PCT, IL-6 were also found. It indicated the obvious inflammatory response among these patients. In addition, we noticed that the increased CRP, PCT concentration and decreased lymphocyte count from admission to death (Supplementary Figure 2), which may represent more prominent inflammation in severe patients. Therefore, intravenous glucocorticoids therapy, intravenous immunoglobulin therapy and interferon-alpha (α-IFN) aerosol inhalation were also used to restore homeostasis, without solid evidence. To our knowledge, there is still no specific medicine for COVID-19 till now. Clinical trials on promising regimens for COVID-19, such as remdesivir, lopinavir, and chloroquine phosphate are ongoing, which shed light on conquering the COVID-19 epidemic¹².

This study has several limitations. First, only 36 dead cases were included. However, this is the largest cohort about the non-survivors of COVID-19 up to now. Second, some specific clinical information was insufficient, such as mechanical ventilation settings, oxygen concentration, and detailed medication history. Third, this is a retrospective, single-centered study. It may be limited to the hospital critical care resources. Further studies are still needed.

In conclusion, most non-survivors are older men with comorbidities (especially cardiovascular diseases). They finally progressed to ARDS. The median time from onset to ARDS was 11 days. The mean survival time in our cohort of COVID-19 non-survivors was about 2 weeks. Gradually decreased lymphocytes and increased inflammation biomarkers were found in these patients, and need to be monitored in the routine treatment. Early detection and intervention of patients are especially important which can delay the development from mild to severe cases.

Contributors

YH, RY,YX collected the epidemiological and clinical data. YH summarised all data. YH, RY, YX, and PG drafted the manuscript. YH and PG revised the final manuscript.

Declaration of interests

We declare no competing interests.

Data sharing

The data will be made available to others on reasonable requests to the corresponding author. Deidentified participant data will be provided after approval from the corresponding author and the Fifth Hospital of Wuhan.