Early signs of disrupted rule learning in adolescents at clinical high risk for psychosis

Background The ability to flexibly apply rules to novel situations is a critical aspect of adaptive human behavior. Evidence from traditional neuropsychological tests suggest that broad executive function deficits appear early in the course of psychosis, but it is unclear which specific facets are affected. Identifying whether rule learning is impacted at the early stages of psychosis are necessary for truly understanding the etiology of psychosis and may be critical for designing novel treatments. Therefore, we examined rule learning in healthy adolescents and those meeting criteria for clinical high risk (CHR) for psychosis.

Methods 24 control and 22 CHR adolescents underwent rapid, high-resolution fMRI while performing a paradigm which required them to apply novel or practiced task rules.

Results Previous work with this task has suggested that practiced rules rely on rostrolateral prefrontal cortex (RLPFC) during task preparation and dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC) during task performance, while novel rules showed the opposite pattern. In controls, we partially replicated this finding with a small effect of greater activity in RLPFC for practiced versus novel tasks; however, the CHR group showed a dysfunctional pattern of results. Not only did the CHR group show alternations in the expected brain dynamics, but they showed weaker effects than controls during both task preparation and task performance.

Conclusions These findings suggest that the critical ability to flexibly apply abstract rules is already disrupted at the clinical high risk stage of psychosis. However, more data is needed to determine whether these deficits predict disease progression.