Independent researchers seeking ethics review

Where a researcher is working independently from any organisation that has an established, formal ethics review process it can be difficult to know how to proceed if the researcher is seeking a review for their project. It is a requirement of many academic journals that an author reporting human research attests to a favourable opinion having been given following a review of the ethics protocol for their research. There is also a moral argument that any human research project that raises ethics issues should be independently reviewed and that the research data collection is not started until a favourable opinion is received.

Some university research ethics committees are open to receiving applications for review from researchers who are not affiliated in any way with the university and are prepared in some cases to give an informal or formal response, either by chair’s action or through a process that involves other committee members, ranging up to full review by the same process as for university-linked research. Contact should be made with the secretary of a university committee to explore what options are available. It is possible that more than one university would need to be contacted before an acceptable agreement can be reached. It should be noted that some universities will charge for this service. Achieving access to ethics review by a university committee could be facilitated by finding an academic member of a university who is prepared to join the research as a co-investigator. Other universities will only offer this service to those working or studying within them.

Some larger charities and commercial organisations that carry out research may also have research ethics committees that might consider reviewing project protocols that fall within their own areas of interest. Here also, seeking an engagement in the project by a researcher within the charity or organisation might facilitate access to review.

There is a small number of independent research ethics committees. These will charge for their services but often on a not-for-profit basis.

Where it is not possible to find a means of gaining a formal review, completing the sample ethics review application proforma in this Code will help to ensure that relevant ethics issues are considered and that there is a documented protocol for the research project.

Minimal risk projects may be considered to not require a formal ethics review. However, establishing that a particular project is indeed minimal risk depends on having carried out a thorough risk assessment.