HIV testing amid COVID-19: community efforts to reach men who have sex with men in three Kenyan counties

Introduction

On 11^th March 2020, the World Health Organization (WHO) declared the spread of COVID-19 a global pandemic after it swept across 114 countries, causing more than 4000 deaths. At the time of writing, SARS-CoV-2 has rapidly spread in 213 countries with an estimated number of 8.6 million persons being diagnosed with the virus, while claiming more than 460,000 lives globally¹.

In an effort to reduce the spread of the virus and mitigate the number of COVID-19-related mortalities, governments globally have introduced various public health measures, including restrictions on international and domestic travel and border controls; increased screening, testing and contact tracing; promotion and implementation of enhanced hygiene programs (i.e. regular handwashing and hand sanitizer use); and use of face masks and physical distancing in public spaces. Some countries have imposed partial or complete lockdowns and enforced curfews to regulate the movement of its citizens. Businesses have been forced either to operate from home or entirely shut down, rendering many workers, outside of those declared “essential”, unemployed. In economically disadvantaged countries like Kenya, these closures and travel restrictions are expected to have a dramatic impact on a national economy that derives most of its GDP from the tourism industry².

Although the COVID-19 epidemic has been less severe in East Africa compared to a number of Euro-American regions, since the announcement of the first COVID-19 case in Nairobi, Kenya, on March 12, 2020, the rate of infection across the country is projected to increase³. At the time of writing, Kenya has reported over 4374 COVID-19 cases across 34 counties, with 119 deaths related to the virus⁴. The Kenyan government has enforced strict measures to prevent the spread of the corona virus and avert a health care crisis in an already fragile health system. These measures include a “dusk to dawn” curfew, inter-county mobility restrictions, mandatory use of face masks in public spaces, and forms of policing that have culminated in violence⁵. Bearing the brunt are the urban poor and daily wage earners who have been intensely victimized by these policing measures⁶.

Working on HIV programs with people whose behaviours are already criminalized in the Kenyan context, we are witnessing the unique and emergent struggles they are encountering⁷. Kenya’s COVID-19 response measures have indeed imposed considerable obstacles to the effective delivery of HIV services to highly marginalized communities such as sex workers and men who have sex with men (MSM). In this paper, we specifically share the implementation experiences surrounding HIV prevention programs serving MSM in Kenya run by three community-led organisations: MAAYGO in Kisumu county, MPEG in Kiambu county and HAPA Kenya in Mombasa county. These programs have more recently attempted to strengthen HIV testing systems, a process that began prior to the COVID-19 epidemic. This program emphasis is highly motivated by recent global health HIV policies that compel program implementers to further their efforts in reaching the “undiagnosed” for a greater “yield” of new diagnoses in order to achieve highly ambitious “90-90-90” (now “95-95-95”) population testing, treatment, and viral suppression targets⁸. The programs that community organizations run to strengthen HIV testing in each of the three county sites in Kenya are technically supported through an ongoing collaboration with health scientists from the University of Manitoba; program specialists from the local NGO, Partners for Health and Development in Africa (PHDA); and health policy officials from The National AIDS and STI's Control Programme (NASCOP), Government of Kenya. In describing the impact of COVID-19 on the MSM community in three contrasting counties of Kenya, we specifically outline the strategies developed and implemented by the community-led organisations to ensure that HIV testing and other key prevention services remain available amid myriad COVID-19-related restrictions and the concomitant fears and anxieties of program beneficiaries.

Impact of COVID-19 on MSM

The MSM-led organizations implementing HIV programs for MSM at each of the three sites mainly include working class men who, during COVID-19, have suffered job losses and unpaid leave like many other working class Kenyans. Many of these men have tended to gravitate toward particular forms of employment in what they regard as “safer” workspaces, but which have been extremely hard hit by the COVID-response measures: the hospitality industry, bars, barber shops and salons, and massage parlors. Many community members also depend on formal and informal modes of sex work, often to augment their income, and have seen the collapse of the sex industry with the closure of hotspots and other public spaces and venues where they normally gather to meet clients. Finding clients through virtual dating sites poses challenges for MSM for two reasons. For one, compared to female sex work, male sex work suffers the additional stigma of “homosexuality”, which has been criminalized by the Kenyan state, and thereby inhibits on-line advertising for sexual services for fear of blackmail. Second, efforts to adhere to physical distancing practices has greatly reduced the pool of available clients.

Loss of jobs and income has had dire financial consequences and led to food insecurity among MSM. Although receiving repeated requests for financial support from members, the ability of CBOs to respond to these needs more fully is greatly constrained by international funding systems on which their programs rely. Financial insecurity has forced some MSM to stay with friends to save on rent, thereby increasing the conditions of overcrowding and COVID-19 exposure risks⁹. Being unable to afford rent, some MSM have been forced to vacate rented homes and now forced to stay on streets. With no source of income and limited resources to sustain livelihoods, it is virtually impossible for these men to afford personal protection equipment (PPE), as directed by the Kenyan government. A number of members who live with one of their sexual partners have begun to report experiences of intimate partner violence, including incidents of forced evictions. For those characterized as “noncompliant” with the government-related COVID-19 guidelines, especially violent, punitive actions taken by police in the form of beatings and arrest, have been brutal in their focus on sex workers, MSM and people who inject drugs. The general sentiment among members we have spoken to is one of anxiety, stress and hopelessness with regards to an unpredictable future.

Impact on HIV testing

According to Kenya’s national guidelines, MSM, like other highly HIV vulnerable “key populations”, are expected to undergo regular testing every three months¹⁰. This health service utilization strategy relies upon regular and intensive peer outreach work (to generate and maintain demand for health services), which must continually confront and break down access barriers related to pervasive stigma¹¹. Amid the COVID-19 pandemic, HIV testing has been greatly disrupted, including among those who regularly test, with clinical attendance waning considerably. Prior to COVID-19, the three CBOs had planned several activities for the period of February to April, 2020, which aimed to increase awareness and acceptance of, and demand for, HIV testing through the promotion and distribution of OraQuick^® HIV self-testing (HIVST) kits. However, because most of these activities relied upon face-to-face outreach and interactions between peers, many of these activities were initially halted with the announcement of COVID-19 response measures. Previously, outreach workers regularly met with their peers in entertainment hotspots and other public venues and cruising places. However, regular and systematic peer outreach, which supported both regular testing in CBO-run clinics and the distribution of HIVST kits to peers, soon collapsed. Furthermore, CBO members were often fearful of coming to the clinic and interacting with clinical staff in each of the three sites, as rumours of COVID-19 transmission stirred fears in their communities.

Physical distancing measures also initially forced the organizations to halt staff meetings, community health forums, and health promotion sessions. Evening curfews were imposed through “cessation of movement” orders within municipal districts, thereby disrupting delivery of services within each of the three sites. Fear and anxiety related to transmission of a new virus (i.e., SARS-CoV-2) also kept the community members away from the clinics. The MSM community could no longer readily move between their homes and the clinic to access services; nor could peer educators and service providers actually reach the clinical facilities. Reviewing the combine program data from the three organizations from January to May 2020 shows how the restrictions impacted upon outreach and clinical services in April 2020 (see Figure 1 and Figure 2).

Figure 1. MSM contacted through peer outreach in the three sites (combined program data, Jan-May 2020).

Figure 2. MSM testing for HIV in the three sites (combined program data, Jan-May 2020).

Although we see noticeable declines in the program performance indicators in the month of April, we can also note some improvement in program performance in the month of May, which is owed to the innovative approaches that the community-based organizations (CBOs) undertook in each of the sites.

Adapting HIV testing programs in response to COVID-19

Addressing safety concerns of service providers and program beneficiaries

Adhering to public health recommendations on COVID-19 infection control, the three CBOs trained their staff on COVID 19 transmission and prevention (see Figure 3). Moreover, the CBOs implemented various safety measures for their staff and program beneficiaries. Each organization placed a water dispenser and handwashing station at the entrance of the office and the clinic. Every individual accessing the premises therefore was expected to wash their hands as they entered. Although few international funders permitted the reallocation of HIV financial aid, UHAI-EASHRI,¹ Africa’s first indigenous activist fund supporting sexual and gender minorities and sex worker human rights, provided grants to respond to the COVID-19 pandemic, thus enabling CBOs to afford protective gear like gloves and masks for clinical staff and peer health workers. For community members and partner organizations unable to afford PPE, CBOs shared their supply of face masks and small bottles of sanitizers, which peer educators packed for distribution (see Figure 4). However, to adhere to physical distancing guidelines, the “safe space” of the three CBO drop-in centres were temporarily closed. Furthermore, the clinic reduced its daily hours of operation to three days a week in the month of April, while requiring clients to make advance bookings to keep the number of CBO clinic attendees to a minimum. While in the clinic, seating arrangements were clearly demarcated, 1.5 meters apart (see Figure 5). All members who visited the clinic were tested for an elevated temperature upon entrance.

In Mombasa, HAPA Kenya decided to formulate a standard operating procedure (SOPs) in response to COVID 19, with its main purpose of ensuring that all beneficiaries would have continued access to HIV prevention commodities. The SOP details how the commodities such as HIV self-test kits, condoms and lubricants, which were previously made available in hotspots, could be safely provided by the program. The SOP was designed to streamline operations for commodities in a way that protected both the CBO frontline health workers and the beneficiaries receiving the services. The SOP also provides programmatic guidance for the effective delivery of HIV commodities to the MSM community that carefully accounted for COVID-19 safety measures. For the SOP to be put into practice, the outreach, clinical and support staff were taken through an intensive training and sensitization sessions on COVID 19.

Figure 3. Intensive COVID-19 training conducted in HAPA Kenya offices, Mombasa.

Figure 4. MAAYGO distributing hand sanitizers, face masks, and liquid soap to a partner organization.

Figure 5. Clients maintaining physical distancing in the public health facility in Kiambu County.

Initiating and strengthening virtual outreach

In light of the shut-down of face-to-face peer outreach activities in public space, the programs soon shifted greater attention to their virtual outreach program to increase the utilization of social media platforms such as WhatsApp and Facebook. In Kiambu, MPEG scaled up their presence in the STEP 1 platform (a virtual platform to access confidential HIV and STI services)¹² through which they started making contact with new community members. MPEG sent more than 9000 messages related to COVID 19 and HIV testing to their members using the bulk SMS platform called the Ujumbe SMS¹³. In Kisumu, each MAAYGO peer educator created a WhatsApp group for their peers where they could lead health education discussions on the spread of the new coronavirus and provide information on how one could access HIV prevention commodities and services during COVID-19. They used the group to also check-in on each other at a time when physical distancing frequently cut people off from vital social support networks. The WhatsApp groups were even used by some peer educators to reach new peers, enabling them to connect through existing social networks. In Mombasa, HAPA Kenya intensified their virtual outreach via dating sites such as Grindr and on Facebook pages by engaging new peer educators to conduct outreach in virtual spaces. Attempting to promote HIV and COVID-19 prevention, HAPA Kenya circulated messages across these virtual sites (see Figure 6) to address widespread fears among the MSM community and enhance trust and rebuild confidence in their organization. HAPA Kenya provided extra cellphone airtime to peer educators for communication, which was urgently needed to maintain contact with their extensive cohorts of contacts, through WhatsApp groups. As part of the health education work conducted on WhatsApp, peer educators increasingly began to notice and speak to emerging mental health issues such as stress, anxiety, fear of loss, while also reminding members to visit the clinic during appointed times to avoid overcrowding. The peers were also requested to encourage their friends to access available services at HAPA-Kenya’s drop-in center. The virtual team, comprised of 14 peer educators, made considerable effort to re-engage members who had once gathered in public hotspots, but had migrated to virtual spaces, so that they could be supplied with vital HIV services including HIVST kits. This team reported finding many of their lost contacts on new virtual platforms, such as TikTok (an app for sharing short videos).

Figure 6. A screenshot showing one of the peer educators using WhatsApp platform to create demand for HIVST (The name “Oscar alpha” is a pseudonym).

Delivering HIV testing services

In the COVID-19 era, CBOs employed innovative strategies to provide HIV testing services to their members. The organizations also saw an increase in demand for HIV Self testing kits. According to the program data, although HIV testing among MSM reduced in the month of April, the use of HIVST kits increased compared to clinic-based rapid testing (see Figure 7).

Figure 7. HIV testing among MSM, by type of test, in three sites (combined program data, Jan–May 2020).

In Kiambu, MPEG partnered with government health facilities, at the county level, to provide services to MSM. This translated into MPEG receiving support in terms of human resources and space. The latter form of support was vital for COVID-19 infection control as all government health facilities maintained strictly prescribed safety protocols. In Mombasa, HAPA Kenya employed a project van and hired public service motor bikes called boda boda to deliver condoms and HIVST kits (see Figure 8). Different boda boda riders were assigned to each of the sub-counties and their schedules were prepared in advance, on a weekly basis, by the outreach team to ensure timely delivery of commodities. In the context of Kisumu, when MAAYGO realised that clinic visits had begun to drop, they started to promote HIVST among those who (previously) frequently and occasionally tested for HIV at their premises. One of the goals of promoting HIVST was to ensure that MSM receiving kits were linked to further prevention and treatment services. During COVID-19, the program continued to implement a centralised follow-up system for those who reported having received and used HIVST kits. CBO clinicians and counsellors conducted follow-ups through phone calls with members.

Figure 8. Peer educator from HAPA delivering commodities to clients on a motorbike.

Ongoing communication and information sharing

The MAAYGO team in Kisumu conducted virtual meetings with staff, peer educators and outreach workers, via zoom video communications (see Figure 9). One of the major and persistent challenges faced during these meeting, however, was internet instability, especially for team members located in rural areas.

Figure 9. MAAYGO staff and outreach workers evaluating project implementation progress.

In Mombasa, between May and June 2020, feedback and program updates between peer educators and managers were organized through group meetings with 15 staff members allowed at one time. In Kiambu, MPEG employed similar methods to conduct meetings with team members to keep abreast of program activities and emerging challenges. Staff and volunteers who needed to join these meetings were provided with extra airtime to enable their participation.

More recently, the CBOs have begun to hold some face-to-face staff meetings, which take place under strict conditions: enough spacing between the meeting participants, wearing face masks, and frequent hand sanitization (see Figure 10).

Figure 10. Meeting held between outreach workers and staff at Railways Health Centre, Kisumu.

Conclusion

Although, in terms of documented infections and mortalities, Kenya has been less impacted by the COVID-19 pandemic in comparison to other countries, our report of three CBOs struggling and persevering in their attempts to offer HIV services to highly stigmatized communities of MSM helps to illustrate the profound disruptions taking place in HIV program delivery [also see 14] in a part of the world where HIV continues to pose a major population health burden and challenge to the effective operation of health systems¹⁵.

In the “end of AIDS” era, where aspirations of “elimination” run high in global health policy discourse that hinges “success” on the amplification of HIV testing and treatment targets¹⁶, COVID-19 profoundly unsettles this optimism. However, despite the myriad challenges initially faced by the three Kenyan CBOs discussed in this report, especially in March and April 2020, towards the end of May program indicators showed a rebounding, greatly owed to the ingenuity and commitment of CBOs in their re-design of strategies for reaching their peers. These efforts were supported by flexibility offered by some funders and the Ministry of Health, which provided guidance and policy support. The adaptation of outreach and program delivery and monitoring was also greatly supported through the flexibility offered by the technical partners; even though “strengthening HIV testing” and HIVST promotion was the initial goal of the collaboration, this flexibility accommodated the room to adapt to the emergent circumstances of COVID-19 with alternative ways of promoting HIV testing. Importantly, this flexibility afforded the space to reveal the unexpected utility of HIVST technologies in a time of crisis, helping community-based programs to resume their role in HIV service delivery amid restrictions on mobility. Indeed, the significance of the community-level responses—which shoulders the responsibility for delivering, distributing and promoting the use of vital HIV services and commodities—arguably must be more fully accounted for in any future epidemic or systemic crisis. Otherwise, we risk trading one crisis for the (re)emergence of another.

Data availability

All data underlying the results are available as part of the article and no additional source data are required.

Consent

Written informed consent for publication of the participants’ images was obtained from the participants.