Abstract
Objectives The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) recommends covering blood-based tests meeting proposed minimum performance thresholds for colorectal cancer (CRC) screening. Outcomes were compared between currently available stool-based screening tests and a hypothetical blood-based test meeting CMS minimum thresholds.
Methods Using the CRC-AIM model, outcomes were simulated for average-risk individuals screened between ages 45-75 years with triennial multi-target stool DNA (mt-sDNA), annual fecal immunochemical test (FIT), and annual fecal occult blood test (FOBT). Per CMS guidance, blood-based CRC screening was modeled triennially, with 74% CRC sensitivity and 90% specificity. Although not specified by CMS, adenoma sensitivity was set between 10-20%. Published adenoma and CRC sensitivity and specificity were used for stool-based tests. Adherence was set at (a) 100%, (b) 30-70%, in 10% increments, and (c) real-world rates for stool-based tests (mt-sDNA=65.6%; FIT=42.6%; FOBT=34.4%).
Results Assuming perfect adherence, a blood-based test produced ≥19 lower LYG than stool-based strategies. At the best-case scenario for blood-based tests (100% adherence and 20% adenoma sensitivity), mt-sDNA at real-world adherence achieved more LYG (287.2 vs 297.1, respectively) with 14% fewer colonoscopies. At 100% blood-based test adherence and real-world mt-sDNA and FIT adherence, the blood-based test would require advanced adenoma sensitivity of 30% to reach the LYG of mt-sDNA (297.1) and approximately 15% sensitivity to reach the LYG of FIT (258.9).
Conclusions This model suggests that blood-based tests with CMS minimally-acceptable CRC sensitivity and low advanced adenoma sensitivity will frequently yield inferior outcomes to stool-based testing across a wide range of adherence assumptions.
Competing Interest Statement
A.M. Fendrick has been a consultant for AbbVie, Amgen, Centivo, Community Oncology Association, Covered California, EmblemHealth, Exact Sciences, Freedman Health, GRAIL, Harvard University, Health & Wellness Innovations, Health at Scale Technologies, MedZed, Penguin Pay, Risalto, Sempre Health, the State of Minnesota, U.S. Department of Defense, Virginia Center for Health Innovation, Wellth, and Zansors; has received research support from the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, Gary and Mary West Health Policy Center, Arnold Ventures, National Pharmaceutical Council, Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute, Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America, the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, the State of Michigan, and the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. V. Vahdat, J.V. Chen, and A.B. Ozbay are employees of Exact Sciences Corporation. D. Lieberman has served on an advisory board for ColoWrap and Freenome. J.J. Karlitz has been a consultant for Exact Sciences Corporation and has an equity position in Gastro Girl. P.J. Limburg serves as Chief Medical Officer for Screening at Exact Sciences. J.B. Kisiel has received research support from Exact Sciences through a contracted services agreement and is an inventor of Mayo Clinic intellectual property, licensed to Exact Sciences, for which he could receive royalties, paid to Mayo Clinic.
Funding Statement
Financial support for this study was provided through a contract with Exact Sciences Corporation. The funding agreement ensured the authors independence in designing the study, interpreting the data, writing, and publishing the report. Exact Sciences Corporation contributed to the study design, data analysis, interpretation of the data, and writing of the report.
Author Declarations
I confirm all relevant ethical guidelines have been followed, and any necessary IRB and/or ethics committee approvals have been obtained.
Yes
I confirm that all necessary patient/participant consent has been obtained and the appropriate institutional forms have been archived, and that any patient/participant/sample identifiers included were not known to anyone (e.g., hospital staff, patients or participants themselves) outside the research group so cannot be used to identify individuals.
Yes
I understand that all clinical trials and any other prospective interventional studies must be registered with an ICMJE-approved registry, such as ClinicalTrials.gov. I confirm that any such study reported in the manuscript has been registered and the trial registration ID is provided (note: if posting a prospective study registered retrospectively, please provide a statement in the trial ID field explaining why the study was not registered in advance).
Yes
I have followed all appropriate research reporting guidelines and uploaded the relevant EQUATOR Network research reporting checklist(s) and other pertinent material as supplementary files, if applicable.
Yes
Footnotes
Financial support: Financial support for this study was provided through a contract with Exact Sciences Corporation. The funding agreement ensured the authors’ independence in designing the study, interpreting the data, writing, and publishing the report. Exact Sciences Corporation contributed to the study design, data analysis, interpretation of the data, and writing of the report.
Conflicts of interest: A.M. Fendrick has been a consultant for AbbVie, Amgen, Centivo, Community Oncology Association, Covered California, EmblemHealth, Exact Sciences, Freedman Health, GRAIL, Harvard University, Health & Wellness Innovations, Health at Scale Technologies, MedZed, Penguin Pay, Risalto, Sempre Health, the State of Minnesota, U.S. Department of Defense, Virginia Center for Health Innovation, Wellth, and Zansors; has received research support from the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, Gary and Mary West Health Policy Center, Arnold Ventures, National Pharmaceutical Council, Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute, Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America, the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, the State of Michigan, and the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. V. Vahdat, J.V. Chen, and A.B. Ozbay are employees of Exact Sciences Corporation. D. Lieberman has served on an advisory board for ColoWrap and Freenome. J.J. Karlitz has been a consultant for Exact Sciences Corporation and has an equity position in Gastro Girl. P.J. Limburg serves as Chief Medical Officer for Screening at Exact Sciences. J.B. Kisiel has received research support from Exact Sciences through a contracted services agreement and is an inventor of Mayo Clinic intellectual property, licensed to Exact Sciences, for which he could receive royalties, paid to Mayo Clinic.
Data Availability
All data produced in the present work are contained in the manuscript
