ABSTRACT
Background and objective Both low and high body mass index (BMI) have been associated with greater mortality in older adults. This study evaluated the trajectory of BMI in the final years of life.
Design Population-based cohort study.
Setting Community-dwelling adults in the English Longitudinal Study of Ageing between 1998 and 2012.
Measurements Body mass index, years before death and all-cause mortality. Analyses were adjusted for age, gender, educational level, housing tenure and social class.
Results Data were analysed for 16,924 participants with 31,857 BMI records; mean age at study start, 61.6 (SD 10.9) years; mean BMI, 27.5 (4.7) Kg/m2. There were 3,686 participants (4,794 BMI records) who died and 13,238 participants (27,063 BMI records) who were alive at last follow-up. Mean BMI increased with age to 60-69 years but then declined, but the age-related decline was more rapid in decedents. At ages 80-89 years, mean BMI in decedents was 26.1 (4.7) compared with 27.1 (4.4) Kg/m2 in survivors. After adjusting for age and covariates, mean BMI declined in the five years before death. From 9 to 5 years before death or end of study, adjusted mean BMI was 0.51 (95% confidence interval 0.24 to 0.78) Kg/m2 lower for decedents than survivors; and from four to zero years before death, 1.55 (1.26 to 1.84) Kg/m2 lower in decedents.
Conclusions In community-dwelling older adults, mean body mass index enters an accelerating decline during five years before death. Reverse causation may account for the association of lower BMI with mortality.
INTRODUCTION
The recent increase in obesity has accentuated the development of multiple morbidity at middle- and older-ages,(1) focusing attention on the association of body mass index with mortality. (2) Meta-analyses of cohort studies suggest that there is strong association between BMI and all-cause mortality (3-5), but there is evidence of ‘U’ or ‘J’-shaped relationship with either low or high body mass index being associated with greater mortality than normal body weight or overweight. (6-9) Similar patterns of association have been reported for systolic blood pressure (10) and total cholesterol values,(11) with either low or high blood pressure or total cholesterol being associated with higher mortality. Longitudinal analysis of blood pressure and cholesterol values recorded into electronic health records found evidence that both blood pressure and total cholesterol values decline towards the end of life. (12, 13) This suggested a possible role of reverse causation in explaining the associations of low blood pressure or low total cholesterol with mortality. We hypothesised that body mass index may show a declining trajectory towards the end of life. We analysed data from a cohort of older adults, the English Longitudinal Study of Ageing (ELSA),(14) in order to evaluate changes in BMI values in the period before death.
METHODS
Study design and participants
A retrospective cohort study was conducted using the English Longitudinal Study of Ageing (ELSA). The initial ELSA cohort included community-dwelling adults aged 50 and over, and their younger partners, drawn from households that responded to the Health Survey for England (HSE) in 1998, 1999 and 2001 (wave 0). Participants were 16,924 participants aged 40-90 years with data for BMI at wave 0. Patients aged less than 40 years were excluded, as were participants aged more than 90 years because their exact ages were not available for analysis. A flow chart for participant and data selection is shown in Supplementary Figure 1.
Participants gave their consent to participate in the study and ethical approval was granted from the London Multicentre Research Ethics Committee.
Measures
Measurements of height and weight were recorded by nurse fieldworkers at waves 0, 2, 4 and 6. Standing height was measured using a portable stadiometer without shoes. One measurement was taken with participants stretching with the head in the Frankfort plane. Weight was measured in light clothing using portable electronic scales.(15) One BMI value of <10 Kg/m2 was omitted. Mortality was all-cause mortality up to February 2012, the latest date when the ELSA study mortality data were updated from the National Health Service Central Data Registry (NHSCR) records. (16) Covariates included age at measurement and the number of years before death. For decedents, years till death was calculated as the difference between the year of death recorded in the ELSA dataset and the year of measurement. For survivors, years till end of study was calculated as 2012 (the last year of mortality follow-up) minus the year of measurement. Because follow-up was conducted in waves, only selected values of years till end of study were possible for survivors. Covariate data from wave 0 included gender, highest educational qualifications (categories: not applicable; Degree or equivalent; Higher education below degree; A Level or equivalent; GCE O Level or equivalent; Other; Foreign qualification; No qualification), housing tenure (categories: Owner; Buying with mortgage; part rent and part mortgage; Rented; live rent free; other and not applicable) and social class (categories: Professional; Managerial technical; Skilled non-manual; Skilled manual, Semi-skilled manual; Unskilled manual; Armed forces; other and not applicable).
Statistical analysis
Mean BMI values were evaluated by age and year till death. Multiple linear regression was used to model repeated BMI values over time, including a random effect at the participant-level using the ‘xtreg’ command in Stata version 14.(17) There was strong evidence that the association of BMI with age and years till death differed by mortality status. Models were fitted separately for men and women who died (decedents) and those who were alive at the end of follow-up (survivors). Age and years till death were fitted as continuous variables, together with quadratic terms to allow for non-linearity, adjusting for education, housing tenure and social class. Predicted BMI from adjusted models were compared with mean BMI values and plotted using the ‘ggplot2’ package(18) in the R program.(19)
RESULTS
The cohort included 31,857 BMI records for 16,924 participants. The mean age at wave 0 was 61.6 (SD 10.9) years with, mean BMI, 27.5 (4.7) Kg/m2. There were 3,686 participants, with 4,794 BMI records, who died; and 13,238 participants, with 27,063 BMI records who did not die at end of follow-up. Table 1 shows the distribution of mean BMI by gender, age-group and years till death or end of study. Mean BMI was generally similar for men and women, but the standard deviation for BMI was greater in women consistent with the greater prevalence of severe obesity in women. In survivors, mean BMI increased from 27.1 Kg/m2 at age 40-44 years, to 28.1 Kg/m2 between 55 to 74 years, before declining to 26.6 Kg/m2 at age 85 to 90 years. A similar pattern was observed in decedents, but the highest BMI was observed between 45 and 64 years and the mean BMI in the oldest age-group was lower at 25.6 Kg/m2. In survivors, mean BMI tended to increase over time from 27.4 Kg/m2 at 14 years before the end-of-study to 28.2 Kg/m2 at the end-of-study. In decedents, mean values were less stable because of the smaller number of observations. However, mean BMI declined in the last five years of life from 27.5 Kg/m2 five years before death to 26.0 Kg/m2 in the last year of life.
Figure 1 (left panel) shows mean BMI values (points) and predicted BMI values adjusted for covariates (lines) by single year of age for survivors (blue) and decedents (red). BMI increased up to approximately age 65 years. Over the age of 70 years, mean BMI declined with each increasing year of age, with the decline being more rapid in decedents than survivors. In survivors, points were generally close to predicted values; in decedents, while points were close to predicted values at older ages, at young ages where there were fewer deaths, there were outlying values of either high BMI values (more evident in men) or low BMI values (more evident in women).
Figure 1 (right panel) shows mean BMI values (95% confidence intervals) by year before death for decedents or end-of-study for survivors, together with predicted values from the adjusted model. Differences between data points and fitted lines may in part be accounted for by covariate adjustment. While BMI remained stable or increased in survivors, there was evidence of declining BMI towards the end of life in decedents. Between zero and four years before death, after adjusting for covariates, BMI was 1.55 (95% confidence interval 1.26 to 1.84) Kg/m2 lower in decedents than survivors; between five and nine years before death, BMI was 0.51 (0.24 to 0.78) Kg/m2 lower in decedents than survivors.
DISCUSSION
Main findings
BMI enters a decline over the age of 65 to 70 years and this decline is earlier and more rapid in decedents than survivors. After adjusting for age and covariates, BMI was found to show an accelerated decline in the last five years of life, and this was not evident at the end of study in survivors. Diehr et al.(20) observed that the processes of ageing and dying may be difficult to distinguish. While body mass index decline may a feature of ageing, accelerated loss of body mass may result from pathological processes leading to mortality.
Consequently, associations of lower body mass index with mortality (9) are likely to be explained by ‘reverse’ causation, where mortality risk is the predictor of BMI.
Strengths and limitations
The present analyses drew on data for a well-established, population-based cohort study with well-described measurement techniques.(14) The main limitations of the study are the limited response rate of 67% at wave 0 and attrition at subsequent waves, (14) leading to a sample that might not be representative over time. Mortality follow-up was restricted to the period up to 2012. Survivors might be misclassified if they died soon after the end of follow-up. Body mass index records were limited to those participants who participated in measurements during years in which follow-up waves of data collection were conducted.
Conclusions and Implications
In the WHO classification of obesity, the mean BMI value for the cohort was consistent with ‘overweight’ rather than ‘healthy’ body weight. For older adults, BMI occupies an ambiguous position with respect to healthy ageing: higher BMI is a risk factor for long-term conditions, including type II diabetes and hypertension; but BMI loss may also be associated with elevated mortality probability. In order to evaluate this, research and clinical assessment might not only consider body weight but also give attention to understanding the prognostic significance of additional indicators including body fat distribution and body composition.
Data Availability
Data for the English Longitudinal Study of Ageing may be accessed through the UK Data Archive.
Acknowledgement
This work was conducted as part of a medical student elective at King’s College London, GKT School of Medicine.